Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

:iconcmc--scootaloo:
It looks good, but what ruins the picture is that you tried to incorporate your own ideas and visions too much.
You not only not added Twilight's key, only because you personally think it should be different, you also let Discord out, despite that he played a major role in the events and was one of the Guardians of the Keys, only because you think he hasn't become a true friend yet (and I smell much Discord aversion here, because the events truly show that he has changed after Tirek betrayed him, which makes it even worse that you ignored him).
And you also not included Silver Shill, despite that he was another Guardian of the Keys, but the Flim Flam brothers instead, that haven't anything to do with the key, and here you didn't even named a reason for that.

It's of course your piece of art, but when you make art that is meant to directly represent episodes or a whole season, you should push your own wishes and opinions back and simply portray what happened.
For incorporating your wishes and opinions, you can make an original piece of art with the characters engaging in new events you thought out, but this shouldn't happen in a picture that is meant to represent episodes or a season.
That's just not right.

I won't favourite nor download this picture. For an overarching post Season 4 fanart, it has just too many mistakes and it just screams "Bah, I didn't like that, I CAN'T draw this!".
2 out of 34 deviants thought this was fair.

Comments


:icondreamerdanielsun:
DreamerDanielsun Featured By Owner Jan 8, 2017  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
TBH it's good to have a little originality sometimes, right? It doesn't hurt anything if it is a little different from the show.
Reply
:iconcmc--scootaloo:
CMC--Scootaloo Featured By Owner Jan 8, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
That's totally fine. A lof of fanart derives, depicts own interpretations or explores alternate possibilities.
My critique was aimed at the intention behind it, he thought that some aspects of the episode sucked, so he decided to "fix it" and pretended he is better than DHX, just based on the fact he would have chosen a different way to write the episode if he would have been the writer.
It is okay to make different interpretations of something for creativity's sake, it is not okay to alter something for the purpose of elevating yourself over another artist, for trying to make yourself look good at the expense of someone else or for criticizing another artist's vision.
That should be common courtesy among all artists, really.
Reply
:icondreamerdanielsun:
DreamerDanielsun Featured By Owner Jan 8, 2017  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Oh, and one more thing. The way you said "you should push your own wishes and opinions back and simply portray what happened." You pretty much told that artist to limit their creativity and keep their originality and their dreams to a minimum, and that is something an artist NEVER does. A common artist always express their originality, wishes and dreams for their entire life unless they want to give up on being an artist; for their creativity is limitless. I know he's stating that this is better than the official content that was there, but really, you should appreciate the work and thought that man had put up with to create this piece.
Reply
:icondreamerdanielsun:
DreamerDanielsun Featured By Owner Edited Jan 8, 2017  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Well then I can see the problem with this critique then. It's not respecting one's opinion about the show. You can't really critize someone over thier intentions of the art. That's actually not much of criticism as it is ranting about someone's opinion.

So he made a "better" alternative version about the show, so what? Is it really insulting towards DHX or Meghan McCarthy in any type of way?
Reply
:iconcmc--scootaloo:
CMC--Scootaloo Featured By Owner Edited Jan 8, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
Most definitely. As I said, if he wants to make an alternate version, to explore creative possibilities (which he didn't, he wanted to defame Meghan McCarthy's work that way, basically saying "What she did is shit, so I make it better!"), then this would have been okay, but he explicitly created this picture to make a negative statement about the episode's writing and that's just despicable, because he bashed Meghan McCarthy's writing that way, just because it wasn't to his taste.

If you create an art piece like this to spite another artist, then you're just abusing art and your artistic expression.
Reply
:icondreamerdanielsun:
DreamerDanielsun Featured By Owner Jan 9, 2017  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Well still, you are not respecting the man's opinion about the show. If he doesn't like the episode then that's his problem, not yours.

Again, this is not a critique, this is a rant about one's opinion. You should've respected that opinion and left it alone but no, instead you're all like "Oh! How dare you dislike the 4th season finale of one of my favorite show about ponies! Here, let me make a rant..er..I mean critique about how you should keep your opinions about the show to yourself along with your originality and ideas of the show!" Doesn't that sound a bit ridiculous? Well, sadly that's what your "critique" screams.

And let's get real here. Would McCarthy even care? Would McCarthy give a single care that someone made a "better" version than the official moneymaking content that is there? No he wouldn't. Wanna know why? Two terms I just used: "official" and "moneymaking". Know that people are gonna be drawn towards the official content more than just a simple fanart, and know that McCarthy is making money out of his content and Rariedash is not.

So really you are looking more of the bad guy for not leaving one's opinion alone, and telling him to limit his opinions and ideas in which an artist always express those things.
Reply
:iconcmc--scootaloo:
CMC--Scootaloo Featured By Owner Jan 9, 2017  Hobbyist General Artist
You continue to miss the point. Either way, if you choose to understand my words or not, creating an art piece to make another artist look bad, because the art piece of that artist is not to your personal taste, then pretend you're better than that artist, is art done out of the wrong motivations.

Art should come from honest inspiration and the desire to try new things to explore their artistic value and potential, not from malicious intent and arrogance like it's the case here.
Reply
:icondreamerdanielsun:
DreamerDanielsun Featured By Owner Edited Jan 9, 2017  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Buddy, I've read the description and call me blind if you want, but I see no malicious intention at all. All I saw was her saying that McCarthy made a mistake on letting Discord be a part about the key and the picture, and I think RarieDash has a pretty good reason as to why. I'm starting to think you are overreacting.

I understand your words. I understand exactly what you are accusing RarieDash of what he's doing. You're telling me that this man is saying that he can do better than the original content that is already there, and that is not the truth. In a way, RarieDash humbly said that this is his version of the story. Not yours, not McCarthy's, not DHX's, not mine, but HIS VERSION. He never even said his version is better. All he said that this is the season just for him, meaning that this is his version of the season.

And I think you've missed a detail. He did not firmly say that McCarthy made a mistake. He humbly said that he THINKS McCarthy made a mistake. Overall though, just be a little less stubborn and leave the man's opinions alone.
Reply
:iconseiya-meteorite:
Seiya-Meteorite Featured By Owner Edited Nov 14, 2016  Hobbyist Filmographer
"It looks good, but what ruins the picture is that you tried to incorporate your own ideas and visions too much./I won't favourite nor download this picture. For an overarching post Season 4 fanart, it has just too many mistakes and it just screams "Bah, I didn't like that, I CAN'T draw this!".

What a prick you are. This is not a critique, this is a "Your picture sucks!" insult. Art is when people express how they see things in their own unique way, or incorporating their own ideas.
Reply
:iconseiya-meteorite:
Seiya-Meteorite Featured By Owner Nov 15, 2016  Hobbyist Filmographer
I don't care what you think of me, from what I know of you (and I'm that same guy who wasted my time with you on EQD), you're just a heartless jerk/troll who does not care for anyone but yourself.

I think you need to see this: cmcscootaloser.tumblr.com/
Reply
:iconcmc--scootaloo:
CMC--Scootaloo Featured By Owner Edited Nov 15, 2016  Hobbyist General Artist
Guilt-tripping me because you don't agree with stuff I'm thinking and because I criticize your hateful, clouded and hopelessly biased stance on the official comics..... Have fun with that, that doesn't work.
Stuff like that just makes me more convinced that I'm right with a lot of things I'm saying.
Thank you, you just added +20 to my resolve.



Also, first randomly calling me out for calling out a jerk artist, then writing a comment only consisting of an insult as answer to my reply and now there's suddenly a link to the Tumblr blog that repeatedly tries to make me famous, posted by you.
Well, that isn't ominous at all.....
Guess I know now who is re-opening that blog that spreads lies and slander about me all the time.
I hope you enjoy your double standard as much as I will enjoy it to copy/paste the same text like last time when I inform the Tumblr support again. :3
Although, I know something that you won't enjoy:

Since you outed yourself very successfully as the creator of this blog, I will do my best to spread word about what you do with it.
Comment here is screenshotted, if I see the blog returning after the Tumblr support deleted it again, I will take action against you.
I can see that you think of me as a ruthless asshole and I can guarantee you that I can be one if I need to.
Don't tempt me and don't strain my patience, Seiya-Meteorite. You would not be the first one who regrets it.
This is the first and only warning you will get.
Reply
:iconrebeccadouglas:
RebeccaDouglas Featured By Owner Sep 15, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Cause art is an expression of yourself. To not incorporate yourself or views into an art piece unless you're some kind of machine. Your "critique" is ridiculous. 
Reply
:iconcmc--scootaloo:
CMC--Scootaloo Featured By Owner Edited Sep 15, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
It is an expression of yourself, however, we're speaking about fanart and there things run a bit differently.

I'm fine with it if someone wants to make an alternate universe drawing to transform some things he/she has seen in the show, but if so, it should be described as such.
In this case, Rariedash was not going to create his own "What if" scenario, he wanted to create a picture that's directly representing the events of the Season 4 Finale that we have seen happen on-screen and yet he changed them anyway.
This picture screams "Bah, some things in this episode were done so terribly, lemme show how it's done RIGHT!" all over the place.
What he did with this picture was the same as if I would draw a picture for "Amending Fences" and swap out Moon Dancer with Twinkleshine without tagging it as "Alternate Universe" and then write in the description:

"Drew something for 'Amending Fences', but replaced Moon Dancer with Twinkleshine, because seriously, having her in this position was just so unfitting it hurt, cause [Insert random reason here] and now I fixed this to show how it SHOULD have been done!"

This is not a piece of art what he did, it's an expression of entitlement.
Which makes it ironically funny at this point that you just told me that art is an expression of the artist, because with how he did draw this picture, he perfectly expressed what an entitled jerk he is.
All he wanted to say with this picture is "Let me show you how terrible this and that in the episode is!".
So, if he wanted to express that he thinks he's better than the writer of the episode, congratulations, he succeeded tremendously with that. :P

This picture is him putting himself over the one who wrote the episode, putting himself over another artist and claiming to be better than she.
Discrediting another artist's art piece and calling it bad is not what art is there for and not a message art should convey and therefore my criticism stands.
Reply
:iconleowolf35:
LeoWolf35 Featured By Owner Sep 15, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Telling people not to fav this or download it is completely low dude. This is their art, if they wanted critique from an ass like you, they would of asked for it.
If they want to draw it that way, they draw it that way. Stop being a critical asshole. You say to develops your own views and shit, but when they do it, you say "Don't fav or download this piece because of the unoriginality"
Wow. Grow up.
This is not a critique, this is HARSH criticism. Which is unfair.
Stop being another Simon and grow up.
Reply
:iconcmc--scootaloo:
CMC--Scootaloo Featured By Owner Edited Sep 15, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
>>>Telling people not to fav this or download it is completely low dude.<<<

Come back when you stop putting things into my mouth.
Maybe we can have a civil discussion then.
Reply
:iconbirdofdestars:
BirdOfDeStars Featured By Owner Jul 29, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
Bah, incorporating your own ideas is what you do in art.
Reply
Add a Comment: